June 17, 1997 Version
PROPOSED RULES OF THE 1997-1998 CONSTITUTION REVISION COMMISSION
CHAIR, OFFICERS, MEMBERS, AND EMPLOYEES
PART ONE - COMMISSION CHAIR
1.1 Appointment of the Chair.--The Chair of the Constitution Revision Commission is appointed by the Governor pursuant to Article XI, section 2(a) of the Constitution of the State of Florida.
1.2 Employment of Executive Director.--The Commission Chair shall employ on behalf of the Commission an Executive Director who shall employ with the approval of the Chair such personnel of the Commission as may be necessary to perform the functions of the Commission. The Executive Director serves at the pleasure of the Commission Chair.
1.3 Appointment of committees.--The Commission Chair, in consultation with members of the Commission, shall appoint all standing and select committees, and the members of each, and unless otherwise provided shall designate a chair and vice -chair of each committee.
1.4 Calling the Commission to order.--The Commission Chair shall take the chair each day at the hour established by the Commission at the last session or by the Committee on Rules and Administration. On appearance of a quorum, the Commissi on Chair shall immediately call the members to order and proceed with the daily order of business.
1.5 Commission Chairís control of order.--The Commission Chair shall decide all questions of order, subject to appeal by any member to the Commission. The Commission Chair may require the member raising the point of order to cite the Rule or other authority in support of the question. Upon appeal, no member (except the member making the appeal) shall speak more than once, except by permission of the Commission Chair. The member making the appeal shall have the right to speak five minutes i n closing, and the Commission Chair shall have the right to speak five minutes from the floor to close the debate.
1.6 The Commission Chairís control of chamber, corridors, and rooms.--The Commission Chair shall preserve order and decorum and shall have general control of the Chamber, galleries, halls, and rooms surrounding the Chamber as well as distr ibution of literature and other materials in those areas.
1.7 The Commission Chairís vote.--The Commission Chair shall not be required to vote in ordinary proceedings, except on final passage of any proposed revision or part thereof of the Constitution, unless the Commission Chairís vote is neede d to break a tie. In all roll call votes, the Commission Chairís name shall be called last.
1.8 Vacating the chair.--The Commission Chair may name any member to perform the duties of the Chair, but such substitution shall not extend beyond one Commission meeting.
PART TWO - COMMISSION OFFICERS: SECRETARY OF THE COMMISSION AND SERGEANT-AT-ARMS.
1.9 Appointment of a Secretary of the Commission.-- The Secretary of the Commission shall be designated by the Commission Chair.
1.10 Secretaryís duties generally; maintains journal.--The Secretary of the Commission shall keep a correct daily Journal of the proceedings of the Commission, and this Journal shall be numbered serially from the first day of the Commissio n meeting in full session. The Secretary shall retain custody of all records or papers belonging to the Commission and shall not permit any records or papers belonging to the Commission to be removed from the custody of the Secretary other than in the reg ular course of business and with proper receipt.
1.11 Secretaryís duties; prepares calendar of public hearing and meeting notice of the Commission.--The Secretary shall publish a calendar as provided by the Committee on Rules and Administration in accordance with these Rules. In the even t the Commission goes into recess, the Secretary shall publish an interim calendar, which sets forth notices of public hearings, and all other matters of public information as shall be necessary to properly advise the members and the public of the officia l meetings of the Commission. Such notice shall be published no less than five (5) days prior to Commission meetings.
1.12 Secretaryís duties; reads papers and calls roll.--The Secretary shall read to the Commission all papers ordered to be read, note responses of members when the roll is called to determine the presence of a quorum; call the roll and tab ulate the answers of members when a question is taken by yeas and nays, and assist, under the direction of the Commission Chair, in taking the count when any vote of the Commission is taken by a show of hands or otherwise.
1.13 Secretaryís duties; prepares printed forms.--The Secretary shall prepare the copy for all printed forms used by the Commission.
1.14 Secretaryís duties; indexes proposals. The Secretary shall maintain a numerical index of proposals filed by members and a cumulative index by introducers.
1.15 Appointment of a Sergeant-at-Arms.--The Sergeant-at-Arms shall be designated by the Commission Chair.
1.16 Duties of the Sergeant-at-Arms.--The Sergeant-at-Arms shall attend the Commission during its meetings, maintain order under the direction of the Commission Chair, and execute the commands of the Commission and all processes issued by the authority thereof as directed by the Commission Chair.
PART THREE - COMMISSION MEMBERS
1.17 Attendance and voting.--Unless excused for just cause, every Commission member shall be within the Commissionís chamber during its sessions and shall vote on each question.
1.18 Excused absence.--The Commission Chair may excuse any member from attendance at any Commission proceeding, and such excused absence shall be noted in the Journal.
1.19 Incurring obligations.--No member of the Commission shall incur any obligation payable from Commission funds without the prior written approval of the Commission Chair.
PART FOUR - EMPLOYEES OF THE COMMISSION
1.20 Executive Director.--The Commission Executive Director serves at the pleasure of the Commission Chair.
1.21 Commission personnel.--The Executive Director with the approval of the Commission Chair may employ such personnel of the Commission as may be necessary to perform the functions of the Commission. The personnel serve at the pleasure of the Chair, and the Executive Director has the authority to dismiss any employee with the approval of the Commission Chair.
1.22 Personnel; duties and hours.--Commission personnel shall perform the duties assigned them by the Commission Chair or the Executive Director and shall remain on duty as required.
PART FIVE - PUBLIC MEETINGS & PUBLIC RECORDS
1.23 Open meetings and records.--All proceedings and records of the Commission shall be open to the public.
COMMITTEES, OFFICERS, MEMBERS,
VOTING, MOTIONS, DECORUM, AND DEBATE
PART ONE - COMMITTEE ORGANIZATION, DUTIES, AND RESPONSIBILITIES.
2.1 Standing substantive committees; creation.--There is hereby created the following substantive standing committees:
1. Declaration of Rights
5. Local Government
6. Finance and Taxation
7. Ethics and Elections
8. Bonding and Investments
Each standing committee shall be composed of no less than five (5) members. Additional standing committees may be named by the chair.
2.2 Standing substantive committees; powers and responsibilities.--The standing substantive committees shall review proposals referred to them by the Chair in relation to the Constitution of the State of Florida, as revised in 1968 and sub sequently amended, and report the results of their deliberations to the full Commission. Any action of a standing committee is advisory only.
2.3 Standing procedural committees.--There is hereby created the following procedural committees:
1. The Style and Drafting Committee. The Style and Drafting Committee shall have the responsibility for clarifying, codifying, and arranging the proposals adopted by the Commission into an orderly revision of or amendment(s) to an existing Sectio n or Article of the present Constitution. It shall also prepare the Commissionís final report.
2. The Rules and Administration Committee. The Rules and Administration Committee shall be responsible for setting the daily calendar and any additions thereto. It shall also see that the proceedings of the Commission, in full session, are in acc ordance with the Rules of the Commission and consider such matters as may be referred to it by the Chair. It shall also provide a schedule of the days and hours for the meetings of the committees to prevent scheduling conflict among members. The committee will also be responsible for working with the Chair and the Executive Director on administrative matters relating to the Commissionís operation.
2.4 Committees; meetings.--Each committee, substantive or procedural, shall meet publicly at such times as are called by the respective committee chair or as determined by the Committee on Rules and Administration, subject to the approval of the Commission Chair. The chair may excuse any member from attendance from committee meetings. The Chair shall group standing committees to provide each with an opportunity to meet without conflicting with the meetings of other committees.
2.5 Committees; quorum.--A majority of the members of a committee shall constitute a quorum.
PART TWO - COMMITTEES; OFFICERS
2.6 Committees; appointment of Chair and Vice-Chair.-- The Commission Chair shall appoint a chair and vice-chair of each committee who shall serve at the pleasure of the Commission Chair.
2.7 Committees; calling committees to order.--The chair or, in the chairís absence, the vice-chair, shall call the committee to order. On the appearance of a quorum, the committee shall proceed with the order of business. Any member of the committee may question the absence of a quorum.
2.8 Committees; chairís control.--The chair or vice-chair shall preserve the order and decorum and shall have general control of the committee room. If there is a disturbance or disorderly conduct in the committee room, the chair or the vi ce-chair may require participants in the disturbance to clear the room.
2.9 Chair and Vice-Chair; vote.--The chair and vice-chair shall vote on all matters before the committee. The name of the chair shall be called last.
PART THREE - COMMITTEES; VOTING
2.10 Committees; taking the vote.--The chair shall declare all votes and shall cause the same to be entered on the records of the committee, but if any member questions a vote, then by a show of hands by three (3) members the chair shall call the roll. When the committee shall be equally divided, the question shall be lost.
2.11 Committees; proxy voting.--Each committee member shall attend all meetings. No member of a committee shall vote by proxy.
PART FOUR - COMMITTEES; CONSIDERATION AND REPORT
2.12 - Committees; consideration of proposals.--All proposals that are referred to a committee established pursuant to these Rules shall be reported from the respective committee in writing, together with the recommendation of approval, disap proval or no recommendation and filed with the Secretary. No proposal may be rejected or defeated by a committee, but a committee, in reporting its recommendation, may draft a new proposal, embracing the same general subject matter of the original prop osal(s) to be returned to the Commission with the recommendation that a substitute be considered in lieu of the original proposal(s).
2.13 Committee consideration; time-frame.--Prior to the convening of the full Commission in session, committees may consider proposals at the pleasure of the chair of the respective committees. When the Commission is meeting in regular ses sions, each committee to which a proposal is referred shall have no longer than three (3) Commission meeting days from the day it received a proposal within which to file its written report, provided however, that on the motion of the committee chair, the time may be extended by the Commission for a period not to exceed five (5) Commission days per motion.
2.14 Committees; failure to report.--In the event a committee fails to report a proposal within the time allowed by these Rules and the time has not been extended, on point of order by the introducer, the proposal shall be deemed reported wit hout recommendation and transmitted to the Secretary to be placed on the calendar for consideration.
2.16 Committees; signing reports.--All committee reports shall be signed by the chair, or the vice-chair in the absence of the chair, and filed with the Secretary. Committees shall keep an accurate record of the committeeís activity includ ing but not limited to motions, amendments, and votes.
2.17 Committees; transmit proposals to Secretary.-- Proposals after having been reported by a committee shall be placed on the calendar for consideration. Proposals shall be listed in numerical order. The Rules and Administration Co mmittee shall establish a calendar for consideration of
proposals and other matters in such order or manner as it
3.1 Objectives.--The Constitution Revision Commission is vested with the duty to examine the Constitution of the State of Florida, as revised in 1968, and subsequently amended, hold public hearings, and file with the Secretary of State its pr oposal, if any. This Rule and each portion thereof addresses itself to the basic document under consideration, proposals for revision and procedures therefor.
3.2 Base document.--The Constitution of the State of Florida, as revised in 1968 and subsequently amended, shall be the base document for all proposals. The Constitution shall be printed in legislative bill form.
3.3 Commission consideration of public issues.-- Constitutional issues raised by the public shall be identified and listed in numerical order according to the article and section of the Constitution to which they relate. Upon motion of a C ommissioner and upon receiving an affirmative vote of at least ten (10) Commission members, issues submitted by the public shall be filed with the Secretary for consideration by the Commission. The moving Commissioner of a public proposal shall be deemed the sponsor of such proposal.
3.35 Commissionersí proposals.--Those issues submitted by Commissioners shall be reviewed by the Commission and upon an affirmative vote of at least ten (10) members, the issue shall be filed with the Secretary of the Commission for consid eration by the Commission.
3.4 Form of proposals.--Proposed revisions to the 1968 Constitution shall be submitted on written forms prescribed by the Secretary. The forms shall follow the form for bills used by the Florida Legislature. A proposal for revision shall a ddress itself to the pertinent article, section, page, and line number of the 1968 Constitution, as amended, which it seeks to revise. Existing language proposed to be deleted shall be lined through with hyphens. Proposed new language shall be unde rlined. A proposal for revision of the Constitution shall be designated a proposal, and shall be referred to as such.
3.5 Proposals for introduction.--All proposals submitted and receiving requisite consideration by Commission members shall be filed with the Secretary who shall serially number them and submit them to the Commission for any action as deter
mined by the Commission. The Commission Chair shall refer proposals to the appropriate
3.6 Substitute proposals.--If a substitute proposal has been filed with the Secretary, when the original proposal is reached on the calendar, it shall be automatically tabled and the substitute proposal shall be available in lieu of the or iginal proposal. Upon failure of a motion to consider the substitute proposal, consideration of the original proposal shall be the next order of business. The introducer of the original proposal may be shown by the Secretary as a co-sponsor of a substitut e or may withdraw as a co-sponsor.
FULL COMMISSION; ORDER OF BUSINESS AND CALENDAR
4.1 Session of the Commission.--The Commission shall meet pursuant to a schedule adopted by the Committee on Rules and Administration and approved by the Commission Chair. The schedule shall set forth the hours to convene and adjourn.
4.2 Quorum.--A majority of the Commission shall constitute a quorum.
4.3 Daily order of business.--The daily order of business shall be as follows.
1. Roll call
3. Pledge of allegiance to the flag
4. Receiving communications
5. Introduction of proposals
6. Reports of committees
7. Matters on reconsideration
8. Special order as determined by the Rules and Administration Committee
9. Unfinished business
10. Correction and approval of journal
The Secretary of the Commission shall prepare and distribute, on each day of session, a calendar corresponding to the Daily Order of Business; and within each order of business, matters shall be considered in the order that they appear on the daily cal endar.
4.4 Motion to amend daily order of business.--Any motion to amend the daily order of business shall be deemed as a motion to waive the rules.
FULL COMMISSION VOTING
MOTIONS AND PRECEDENCE
6.1 Motions; how made, withdrawn.--Every motion other than a motion to amend a proposal under consideration, shall be made orally. At the request of the Commission Chair any motion shall be reduced to writing. After a motion has been stated o r read by the Commission Chair, it shall be deemed to be in possession of the Commission and, without a second, shall be disposed of by a vote of the Commission. The mover of the motion may withdraw a motion, except a motion to reconsider, as hereinafter provided, at any time before the same has been amended or before the vote shall have commenced.
6.2 Motions; precedence.--When a question is under debate, the Commission Chair shall receive no motion except:
1. To adjourn instanter
2. To adjourn at a time certain
3. Questions of Privilege
4. To take a recess
5. To reconsider
6. To limit debate
7. To postpone to a day certain
8. To commit to a standing committee
9. To commit to a select committee
10. To amend
Those motions shall have a precedence in the descending order given above. The Commission Chair shall propound all questions in the order in which they are moved unless the subsequent motion be previous in nature; except that in fixing time, the longes t time shall be put first. In all cases where the Commission shall be divided, the question shall be lost.
6.3 Motions which can be made but once.--Motions to adjourn or recess shall be decided without debate by a majority vote of those present and voting. Only one substitute for a motion to adjourn shall be entertained. The substitute motion s
hall fix a different time for adjournment, and the same shall be put without debate, except that one (1) minute shall be allowed for the movers
6.4 Division of question.--Any member may call for a division of a question when the sense will admit it. A motion to strike and insert shall be deemed indivisible; a motion to strike out, being lost, shall neither preclude amendment nor a motion to strike out and insert.
6.5 Reconsideration; generally.--When a main question has been made and carried or lost a Commissioner voting with the prevailing side may move for reconsideration of the question on the same or the next day on which the Commission meets. If the question has been decided by voice vote, any Commissioner may so move. Such motion may be made pending a motion to adjourn or if it is time to adjourn. Consideration of a motion to reconsider shall be a special and continuing order of business for the full Commission when it next meets as the full Commission succeeding that on which the motion was made and, unless considered on said business day, shall be considered abandoned. If the Commission shall refuse to reconsider or, on reconsideration, sha ll confirm its first decision, no further motion to reconsider shall be in order except on unanimous consent of those present. When a majority of Commissioners present vote in the affirmative on any question but the proposition be lost because it is one i n which the concurrence of more than a majority is necessary for adoption or passage, any Commissioner may move for reconsideration. On the last day on which the Commission meets, a motion to reconsider shall be taken up instanter.
6.6 Reconsideration; when debate allowed.--Debate shall be allowed on a motion to reconsider only when the question which it is proposed to reconsider is debatable. Where debate upon a motion to reconsider is in order, no member shall spea k thereon more than once nor for a longer period than five (5) minutes.
6.7 Reconsideration; collateral matters.--The adoption of a motion to reconsider a vote upon any secondary matter shall not remove the main subject under consideration from the consideration of the Commission. A motion to reconsider a coll ateral matter must be disposed of at once during the course of consideration of the main subject to which it is related and such motion shall be out of order after the Commission has passed to other business.
AMENDMENTS 7.1 General form; notice; manner of consideration.-- All amendments shall be filed with the Secretary of the Commission on forms prescribed by the Secretary, but shall be considered only after the sponsor gains recognition from the Chair to move for adoption.
7.2 Sequence of amendments to amendments.--An amendment to a pending amendment may be received, but until it is disposed of, no other motion to amend will be in order, except a substitute amendment or an amendment to the substitute. Such a mendments are to be disposed of in the following order:
1. Amendments to the amendment are acted on before the substitute is taken up. Only one amendment to the amendment shall be in order at a time.
2. Amendments to the substitute are next voted on. 3. The substitute then is voted on.
The adoption of a substitute amendment in lieu of an original amendment shall be treated and considered as an amendment to the bill itself.
7.3 Amendment by section.--The adoption of an amendment to a section shall not preclude further amendment of that section or article. If an article is being considered section by section or item by item, only amendments to the section or i tem under consideration shall be in order. The Commission Chair shall, in recognizing members for the purpose of moving for adoption of amendments, try to consider all amendments to Section 1 first, then all amendments to Section 2 and so on. After all se ctions have been considered separately in lieu of the entire article, the whole article shall be open for amendment.
7.4 Amendment; germanity of amendment.--No proposition on a subject different from that under consideration shall be admitted under color of amendment.
DECORUM AND DEBATE
8.1 Decorum and debate.--When any member desires to speak or deliver any matter to the Commission, the member shall rise at his or her seat and address the Chair as Mr. or Madam Chair, and, on being recognized, may address the Commission from his or her desk, and shall confine any remarks to the question under debate, avoiding personality. A member shall not address or refer to another member by his or her first name. A member shall use the appellation of Commissioner, or such appeallation an d the surname of the Commissioner addressed.
8.2 Commission Chairís power of recognition.--When two (2) or more members rise at once, the Commission Chair shall name the member who is first to be recognized.
8.3 Interruption of members in debate.--No member shall be interrupted by another member without the consent of the member who has the floor, except rising to a question of order.
8.4 Time for debate.--No member shall speak more than ten (10) minutes in debate on any question. The introducer of a proposal under consideration shall be entitled to five (5) minutes to close, notwithstanding that the introducer may have used ten (10) minutes in opening.
8.5 Limitation on debate.--When a proposal is under debate by the Commission, a member may move to limit debate, and such motion shall be decided without debate, except the introducer of a proposal shall have five (5) minutes to discuss sa id motion. If, by two-thirds (2/3) vote of those present, the question is decided in the affirmative, debate shall be limited accordingly.
8.6 Priority of business.--All questions relating to priority of business shall be decided without debate.
8.7 Questions of privilege.-- Questions of privilege shall be: (1) those affecting the Commission collectively, its safety, dignity, and the integrity of its proceedings; and (2) the rights, reputation, and conduct of members individually in their representative capacity only. These shall have precedence over all other questions except motions to adjourn. Upon recognition of the Chair, no member shall be permitted to speak longer than ten (10) minutes on a question of privilege.
9.1 Interpretation of rules.--It shall be the duty of the Commission Chair, or the presiding officer, to interpret all rules.
9.2 Waiver and suspension of rules.--These rules shall not be waived or suspended except by a two-thirds (2/3) vote of all the members of the Commission. The motion, when made, shall be decided without debate. No motion to waive a rule req uiring unanimous consent of the Commission shall be adopted except by unanimous consent of those present.
9.3 Changes in rules.--All proposed amendments to these Rules shall be presented to the Rules and Administration Committee for recommendation to the Commission. Such recommendation may be amended by a two-thirds (2/3) vote of the Commissio n and shall be adopted by a two-thirds (2/3) vote of the Commission.
9.4 Majority action.--Unless otherwise indicated by these rules, all action by the Commission shall be by majority vote of those members present.
9.5 Supreme Court library temporary repository for Commission records.--The Supreme Court library shall be provided with copies of the records for the purpose of creating an electronic record of the Commission process. All records of the C ommission will be permanently stored with the Secretary of State, Division of Library Information Services, Bureau of Archives and Records Management.
9.6 Alternates.--Alternates shall have the same privileges as Commissioners, but shall not have voting privileges.